Great Conversations or Arguments?

586 Bastille Day The French love to argue. Often, I come away from a conversation with my husband feeling like we’ve had a fight, while he comes away from the same conversation thinking it was a really good discussion.

Honestly, it drives me crazy.

It’s not that I don’t enjoy good banter, or analyzing things, or getting in depth on politics, history, world events, etc. It’s just that I don’t enjoy it All. The. Time. Sometimes I want to kick back, have a drink, and laugh until my abs hurt. Americans, especially females, look to connect and find common ground through conversation. With my husband, I often feel like he takes the opposing stance just because it’s fun for him. As Olivier Magny points out in Stuff Parisians Like, the French don’t have conversations, they win them.

Often, our conversations will end with this:

Me: “Wait, that’s exactly the point I was making.”

Stéphane: “Yes. We’re violently agreeing.” Big smile, laugh.

Me: “Then why were you arguing with me?”

Stéphane: “Oh, that wasn’t arguing, was it?”


I’ll never forget the first time we hung out with P (name withheld to protect the innocent … or to protect me from the wrath of a Frenchman) and his wife. The topic came around to – surprise – politics. P had been eyeing me but not really including me in the conversation. I felt like I was being sized up; like he was calculating whether or not I would become a friend, accepted into this circle of Frenchies. He turned to me. “J’ai une question pour toi.”


His question had to do with Arizona politics. Being from Arizona and socializing in French circles has been a challenge considering the political climate of my home state. I don’t live there and hate much of what has been done there, yet I still feel embarrassed and defensive when people ask me: what is Arizona’s problem?

After he posed his question, I asked, in French, “Are you asking for my opinion on the new law, or are you asking me what it is about Arizona and the politics there that has allowed these things to come to pass?”

He eyed me very seriously and nodded his head. “Bon retour.”

Excellent return. Like we were in some sort of sporting match. I realize now that to him, we were. I held my own, and we became friends.

Every once in a while, during a dinner with French friends where politics and philosophy are being volleyed around, people are talking over each other, voices are rising, I have the urge to blurt out: “ ‘I see Blue. He looks glorious!’ …. Will Ferrell? …. Old School? …. Anyone?” Or perhaps more to the point: “I’d like to have an argument, please,” à la John Cleese.

I always joke that the French make things way more complicated than they need to be. Even our simple saying for plucking petals from a flower: “He loves me, he loves me not,” becomes complicated in French: “Il m’aime un peu, Il m’aime beaucoup, Il m’aime passionément, Il m’aime à la folie, Il m’aime pas du tout.” He loves me a little, he loves me a lot, he loves me passionately, he’s crazy for me, he doesn’t love me at all.

The fact that my husband is an engineer from France makes it even harder. Let’s. Analyze. Everything.

“Hey, Stef, could you dry the high chair tray with a towel after you wash it? If you prop it over the sink it’s never dry when I need it at lunch time.”

“It doesn’t get dry? Hmmm. I could look into devising a ventilation system where we could have it propped away from the wall and direct more air flow onto it so the droplets evaporate properly. It would involve using the window and working to control ambient temperatures. I might need to do some internet research to see how others have addressed this problem.”

“Or, you could just dry it with a towel.”

Okay, maybe that conversation didn’t quite happen that way.

However, I’m proud to say that on that “great discussion” I came out the winner.


20 thoughts on “Great Conversations or Arguments?

  1. When arguing with French people, I’m always ready to “go all-in”, so to speak. They tend to make an uproar out of nothing, therefore I prefer to avoid any discussion completely, or if I can’t avoid it, f.i. in business matters, I’m prepared to make an even bigger uproar.
    I admit my ignorance and I’m a little ashamed, but I have no idea about what kind of Arizona’s laws we’re talking about…. to me Arizona + politics = John McCain. What terrible things happened there?

    • Joe Arpaio, Maricopa County sheriff is constantly in the news for his … methods. Pink underwear on inmates, ignoring sex crimes, racist practices, a devout believer, and pusher, that Obama’s birth certificate is a forgery…. Jan Brewer, governor, is consistently embarrassing to the state (look either one up on Wikipedia and scroll to controversies – the lists are long, especially for Arpaio). Arizona SB 1070 – the most restrictive and racist immigration “reform” passed …. My face is now flaming in embarrassment for my state.

  2. I know how this feels! So often I feel like we’ve had an argument that’s blown up over nothing, but he only sees it as an interesting discussion. Now I just say “shut up and agree with me”, which usually works 😉

  3. Wow I know exactly how you feel! With my boyfriend after what he thinks is a “great discussion” he asks me, “why are you getting so upset??” Haha and it’s so true that even agreeing seems like an argument sometimes!

    • Ten years and my husband and I are still dealing with this major cultural difference. He still doesn’t understand why I get upset, I still don’t understand why everything becomes an argument 🙂 C’est la vie, je suppose!

  4. Pingback: Praise from Caesar – The Dilettante Edition, June 15, 2013 | Being the Memoirs of Helena Hann-Basquiat, Dilettante.

  5. Oh, this sounds like my husband: “Yes. We’re violently agreeing.”

    He come from Italian stock, and ADORES playing Devil’s Advocate just to keep the conversation rollicking. It makes me insane, but I can honestly say that, in almost five years together, I have literally *never* been bored while he was in the room.

      • Lol your husband sounds exactly like my father, who is also an engineer. Sometimes, he disagrees with me to aggravate me, well, that’s what I think anyway. He agrees with me in principle but doesn’t like one word I used in my statement. We drive my poor mum insane because we are French but we have Italian origins. It always end up being a contest as to who shouts the loudest.
        Your blog really looks interesting. I’m about to read the one about scary children’s book.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s